Two Competing Plans To End Shutdown, One With Border Wall Funding, Fail In Senate

On Thursday, two competing bills in the Senate to end the partial government shutdown, one of which included funding for the border wall, failed.

The stalemate over border security between President Donald Trump and Republican lawmakers and their Democratic counterparts thus means the government shutdown — which entered its 34th day on Thursday — will continue.

Trump’s plan that demanded $5.7 billion for the steel border barrier failed with 50 “yes” votes and 47 “no” votes. The second bill — which excluded border wall funding and would have provided additional federal funds through Feb. 8 — earned 52 votes for and 44 votes against. Each package required 60 votes to pass.

Six GOP lawmakers broke party ranks to vote for the bill that excluded wall funds. This result shows that despite many House Republicans being opposed to Trump’s views on the barrier and shutdown, the overwhelming majority of the Senate remains loyal to the president.


A week of political news in your in-box.
We find the news you need to know, so you don't have to.

Last weekend, Trump proposed a plan that in exchange for border wall funds would offer limited protections for immigrants, especially young migrants who came to the U.S. as children under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program. However, Democrats rejected this offer.


Democratic leaders called the Senate’s bill on Thursday a “nonstarter,” largely because it significantly reduced DACA eligibility criteria and extended it for just three years. The plan also reportedly made changes regarding asylum laws that would make it harder for refugees fleeing persecution and violence to come to the U.S.

“I’m still optimistic in the goodness of the Republicans in the Senate, that they will care enough about these people that they will say, ‘Ok, we’ll give two weeks so that we can negotiate an evidence-based, cost-effective, value-respecting way to protect the American people with border security,’ ” said House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), according to The New York Times. “That doesn’t seem like a big ask.”

In a tweet on Thursday, Trump fired back at Pelosi’s comment regarding her lack of understanding for the necessity of a border wall.

Pablo Mena

Writer for NY Giants and Rangers fan. Film and TV enthusiast (especially Harry Potter and The Office) and lover of foreign languages and cultures.

Recent Posts

GOP Sen. Jame Lankford Finds Himself Politically Weakened At Home In Oklahoma After Negotiating Border Deal

After the Oklahoma Republican Party censured Sen. James Lankford for negotiating a bill to secure…

13 hours ago

Wisconsin Gets New Legislative Maps Ending A Decade Of GOP-Gerrymandered Dominance

Democrats in Wisconsin received a rare win on Monday when Democratic Gov. Tony Evers signed…

14 hours ago

Trump Reportedly Favors 16-Week National Abortion Ban

Former President Donald Trump reportedly favors a 16-week national abortion ban, with exceptions for rape,…

2 days ago

Democratic Presidential Candidate Dean Phillips Fires Majority Of Campaign Staff Amid Poor Fundraising

Democratic presidential candidate Dean Phillips announced that he would lay off a significant portion of…

2 days ago

Republican Seek To Make The Most Of Special Counsel Hur’s Biden Report

After an investigation that has spanned a year, carried out by Special Counsel Robert Hur,…

3 days ago

New Congressional Map For New York Doesn’t Help Democrats As Much As Expected

A bipartisan re-districting committee in New York has approved a new congressional map that makes…

3 days ago