News

Sotomayor Denounces Supreme Court Ruling On Prisoners’ Rights As ‘Perverse’ & ‘Illogical’

A Supreme Court ruling will make it more difficult for prisoners to be released, disallowing new evidence to be presented in federal court to support arguments that state lawyers did not adequately represent them.

The vote was 6-3 along party lines, and Justice Clarence Thomas wrote the majority opinion for the case dealing with consideration of new information in the cases of death row inmates David Martinez Ramirez and Barry Lee Jones of Arizona, years after they had already been convicted. He ruled that federal courts should only be able to take into consideration evidence that was already presented in the state court.

Ramirez was convicted of murdering his girlfriend and her 15-year-old daughter in 1989. Evidence also suggested that he had raped the daughter, which he admitted to.

Jones was sentenced to death in 1995 for assaulting and killing 4-year-old Rachel Gray.

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!

A week of political news in your in-box.
We find the news you need to know, so you don't have to.

Left-leaning Justice Sonia Sotomayor penned a biting dissent, arguing that prisoners’ lives could be ended without Constitutionally promised counsel, beyond the two cases in question.

“This decision is perverse. It is illogical,” she wrote. “The Sixth Amendment guarantees criminal defendants the right to the effective assistance of counsel at trial. This Court [in Martinez] has recognized that right as ‘a bedrock principle’ that constitutes the very ‘foundation for our adversary system’ of criminal justice.”

“Today, however, the Court hamstrings the federal courts’ authority to safeguard that right. The Court’s decision will leave many people who were convicted in violation of the Sixth Amendment to face incarceration or even execution without any meaningful chance to vindicate their right to counsel,” she added.

Rose Carter

Recent Posts

VIDEO: Trump Administration Deports 200 Venezuelan Gang Members To El Salvador Despite Judge’s Order Blocking Flight

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/3ZUtrFbEfUU The United States deported more than 200 alleged members of a Venezuelan gang to…

3 hours ago

Trump Considers Lifting Sanctions Against Russia As US Aims For Ukraine Peace Deal

The United States is reportedly preparing to potentially give Russia sanctions relief as President Donald Trump seeks…

5 hours ago

Chaos Ensues At National Nuclear Security Administration After DOGE Rescinds Firings Of Key Staffers

After rescinding broader layoffs in mid-February, President Donald Trump and adviser Elon Musk have purged 50 workers from the Department of Energy.…

7 hours ago

Amid Measles & Bird Flu Outbreaks, Department Of Health & Human Services Offers All Workers $25K Voluntary Buyout Offer

Eighty thousand federal workers at the Department of Health and Human Services were emailed with…

10 hours ago

Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem Says $200 Million Ad Campaign Thanking Trump For ‘Closing The Border’ Was His Idea

The $200 million tax-payer financed Department of Homeland Security ad campaign that aired in late…

11 hours ago

VIDEO: Veterans March Against Trump In Minnesota

https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Ng5OC-49f6o A crowd containing many veterans protested against the policies of President Donald Trump in Edina, Minnesota,…

1 day ago