News

Alan Dershowitz Absent From Senate Floor After Strong Criticism Of Trump Defense Argument

President Donald Trump‘s star impeachment defense attorney, Alan Dershowitz, tried to clarify his arguments from Wednesday that anything a president does to get reelected is not impeachable.

The Harvard law professor was missing from the Senate floor Thursday, after making an argument that has come under fire by several constitutional law experts.

On Wednesday, he said if a “hypothetical” president pressured a foreign country to build a hotel with their name on it, it would clearly be an act of corruption. But if their actions were part of an attempt to get reelected, they would be acting in the “national interest.”

“But a complex middle case is ‘I want to be elected. I think I’m a great president. I think I’m the greatest president there ever was and if I’m not elected, the national interest will suffer greatly,'” Dershowitz said to the Senate. “That cannot be an impeachable offense.”

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!

A week of political news in your in-box.
We find the news you need to know, so you don't have to.


He attempted to clarify his comments Friday, saying he never said that “a president can do anything if he thinks his election’s in the national interest.”

“I never said, never suggested and it was a total distortion — not misunderstanding – distortion of my point that I think a president can do anything if he thinks his election’s in the national interest. Never said it. It’s nonsense.”


On Friday, Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-New York) tore apart Dershowitz’s argument, saying that by that logic, “President Nixon did nothing wrong in Watergate. He was just breaking into the DNC to help his reelection, which of course is in the public interest.”

He also acknowledged Dershowitz’s television appearances.

“I hear he’s correcting it on TV today,” Schumer said. “But that seems to be Mr. Dershowitz’s pattern. He gives a statement on the floor and then spends the next day correcting it. What a load of nonsense.”


Dershowitz responded to Schumer’s interpretation of his argument on Twitter, saying Nixon was impeachable because he “committed numerous crimes.”


His argument that an impeachable must be an indictable crime, as in the case of Nixon, has been challenged by several legal scholars.

Frank Bowman, a University of Missouri law professor and former student of Dershowitz’s at Harvard Law School, called the idea “rubbish” to PBS Newshour.

Jonathan Turley, a George Washington University law professor who argued to the House against impeachment, wrote in a Washington Post op-ed that such an argument was “politically unwise and constitutionally shortsighted.”

“The developing defense by the White House is also a mistake,” Turley wrote. “It would again ‘expand the space for executive conduct’ by reducing the definition of impeachable conduct to the criminal code. It is an argument that is as politically unwise as it is constitutionally shortsighted.”

 

Katherine Huggins

Recent Posts

Trump Prosecutor Alvin Bragg Agrees To Testify Before House

Manhattan District Attorney Alvin Bragg, who led prosecution of former President Donald Trump, has agreed…

21 hours ago

Supreme Court Rejects Lawsuit To Restrict Mifepristone Abortion Pill

On Thursday, the Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the Alliance for Hippocratic Medicine's attempt to restrict…

21 hours ago

Trump Meets With Congressional Republicans Amid House GOP Divisions

On Thursday, former president and presumptive Republican nominee Donald Trump made his first visit to…

21 hours ago

Progressive Democrats Consider Boycotting Netanyahu’s Congressional Address

Last week, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was invited to address Congress in Washington, D.C.…

2 days ago

House GOP Votes To Hold A.G. Merrick Garland In Contempt Of Congress

On Wednesday, House GOP members voted to hold Attorney General Merrick Garland in contempt of…

2 days ago

Biden Administration Proposes Regulation Banning Medical Debt From Credit Reports

On Tuesday, the Biden Administration proposed a federal regulation to exclude medical debt from credit…

2 days ago