News

Special Counsel Jack Smith Can Keep Trump’s DMs, Appeals Court Rules

On Tuesday, an appeal brought by X, the social media platform formerly known as Twitter, in a federal court regarding a search warrant and nondisclosure agreement over former President Donald Trump‘s Direct Messages and data issued by Special Counsel Jack Smith was denied.

X appealed on the basis that the nondisclosure agreement limited their First Amendment rights. The special counsel insisted that the NDA was in place to keep Trump in the dark about moves being made in the investigation.

The court upheld the nondisclosure agreement. But in the appeal, the scope of information the special counsel sought access to has been revealed. It included all of Trump’s direct messages, devices used to access the account, his drafts folder and any communication the former president engaged in directly with X.

X argued that turning over the data would infringe on Trump’s executive privilege, a point the dissenting judges agreed with.

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!

A week of political news in your in-box.
We find the news you need to know, so you don't have to.

Judge Neomi Rao, who was appointed by Trump, said that the special counsel violated “the careful balance Congress struck in the Presidential Records Act.” However, the majority of the court ruled to uphold the warrant and nondisclosure order.

This is not X’s first attempt at fighting the special counsel and their criminal investigation of Trump. X was first served the warrant for access to Trump’s data in January 2023. Upon granting the warrant, the federal district court agreed that “it was reasonable to believe disclosure of the request would result in the destruction of or tampering with evidence, intimidation of a potential witness and serious jeopardy to the investigation.”

X failed to comply with the warrant initially and was held in contempt by a D.C. district court. A fine of $350,000 was levied upon X and the data Smith was seeking was eventually turned over to his office.

In August 2023, X’s first appeal was made to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit and was rejected by a three-judge circuit court panel, keeping X bound by the nondisclosure order.

Then, in September, X asked for a rehearing before the court’s entire slate of judges in what is known as an “en banc” rehearing, arguing that the prior decision was incorrectly decided. The appeal was rejected Tuesday, with seven of the 11 judges voting to uphold the warrant and nondisclosure order.

U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell called the efforts by X to deny a federally issued warrant and nondisclosure order “extraordinary.” She speculated that the fight being put up by X owner Elon Musk and his company is an attempt to “cozy up to Trump,” according to court transcripts.

Clark Franzman

Recent Posts

VIDEO: Transgender Activist Confronts GOP Rep. Nancy Mace At D.C. Summit

A prominent transgender-rights activist disrupted a talk involving Rep. Nancy Mace (R-South Carolina) in Washington,…

2 days ago

Biden’s Historic Climate Policies Are Poised To Be Undone By Trump

After President-elect Donald Trump's victory, experts have expressed serious doubts about the future of the Biden…

2 days ago

VIDEO: Trump Watches SpaceX Launch Alongside Elon Musk & Ted Cruz

https://youtube.com/shorts/YVrfbMZSVRE?feature=share US President-elect Donald Trump drew cheers as he arrived in Texas on Nov. 19 to watch…

5 days ago

Foreign Policy Experts Voice Concern About Trump’s Nomination Of Tulsi Gabbard For Director Of National Intelligence

After President-elect Donald Trump selected Tulsi Gabbard, a former Democratic congresswoman, as his nominee for…

6 days ago

Trump’s Pick Of Vaccine-Skeptic Robert F. Kennedy Jr. As Department of Health & Human Services Secretary Alarms Scientific Community

President-elect Donald Trump's announcement that Robert F. Kennedy Jr. will be his pick for Department…

1 week ago

VIDEO: President-Elect Donald Trump, Elon Musk & Cabinet Picks Attend UFC Fight In NYC, Crowd Chants “USA”

https://youtube.com/shorts/6CUvTmS87UM?feature=share President-elect Donald Trump arrived to cheers at an Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) event in…

1 week ago