News

Experts Worry That Judge Aileen Cannon Is Not Suited To Handle Trump’s Case

Federal District Court judge Aileen Cannon has been randomly assigned to preside over the case of Donald Trump’s mishandling of classified documents. But experts are questioning her competence and ability in handling such historic legal proceedings.

Trump is the first former president to ever face criminal charges. He appointed Cannon in 2020, right after he lost the election to President Joe Biden. She had no previous experience as a judge and formerly worked on appellate cases as an assistant United States attorney in Florida.

Under the Southern District of Florida’s practices, a computer in the clerk’s office assigned cases to judges who sit in the division where the matter occurred. Five active judges were eligible to take on the case, but Cannon was chosen at random.

According to a Bloomberg Law database, Cannon has been assigned 224 criminal cases since 2020. Only four of those cases, though, actually went to trial. She has dealt with basic charges, such as possession of a gun and tax fraud. Many fear that her experiences do not qualify her to take on Trump’s case.

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter!

A week of political news in your in-box.
We find the news you need to know, so you don't have to.

Cannon will be faced with many challenging decisions throughout the litigations. Conflict will arise concerning what evidence is permissible in court since the files that Trump took contain highly classified national security information. She will presumably be asked by defense lawyers to suppress evidence and testimony against Trump and will have to make calls about the biases of jurors on the case.

The young judge is already facing scrutiny about her loyalties to Trump. Aside from being appointed by him, Cannon sided with Trump at an earlier stage of the documents case. She suggested that, as a former president, he should get special protections that other targets of search warrants would not need. This motion was reversed by a conservative appellate court that ruled she did not have the authority to make this decision.

According to a federal law stating that judges are supposed to recuse themselves if their “impartiality might be reasonably questioned,” Special Counsel Jack Smith could ask Cannon to step back from the trial. If she were to decline to recuse herself, an appeals court could order her to do so.

However, there is no indication that Smith will ask her to recuse herself, nor that she will step back on her own. Many are still hesitant about her ability to rule fairly and remain professional throughout the trial.

Ava Lombardi

View Comments

  • Having a Trump appointed judge will on one hand show that he is getting an edge but on the other hand she will have to be impartial as she will be under a judicial microscope. A good balance.

    The jury is another issue; it only takes one Trump fanatic to overturn the truth

Recent Posts

Virginia GOP Lt. Gov. Candidate John Reid, Accused Of Running Explicit Gay Tumblr, Says Gov. Glenn Youngkin’s Team Is ‘Extorting’ Him

A resurfaced audio recording reveals Matt Moran, the top political strategist for Virginia Gov. Glenn…

9 hours ago

Supreme Court Allows Trump Administration To Implement Its Transgender Military Ban

The U.S. Supreme Court allowed President Donald Trump's administration to place a ban on transgender…

14 hours ago

Israel Approves Plan To Reoccupy Gaza Strip Indefinitely

On Monday, Israel’s cabinet approved a plan to reoccupy the Gaza Strip for an indefinite…

2 days ago

Trump Administration Offers Undocumented Migrants $1000 To Self-Deport

On Monday, the Department of Homeland Security announced a new program offering undocumented immigrants a…

2 days ago

Trump Says He ‘Doesn’t Know’ Whether He’s Obligated To Uphold The Constitution In Startling Interview

President Donald Trump raised eyebrows after answering he was unsure whether he is obligated to…

2 days ago

Former House Speaker Nancy Pelosi Slams Trump Plan To Reopen Alcatraz As ‘Unserious’

President Donald Trump has announced plans to reopen Alcatraz, the infamous maximum-security prison in San…

2 days ago